Quality of Life Score
47.01
State Comparison
Alabama vs New York
Alabama is cheaper overall, while $100 goes further in Alabama, New York has higher incomes, Alabama has lower state income tax, and Alabama gets more sunshine.
Alabama
17
/ 30
metrics won
Score
VS
New York
13
/ 30
metrics won
AL wins Housing
AL wins Quality of Life
AL wins Climate
NY wins Income
Quality of Life
Composite score — income, affordability, education, health, and safety.
Alabama
vs
New York
winner
New York scores higher on quality of life — 10.93 points difference.
Overview
Key differences overview
These cards keep the comparison factual first, so the biggest tradeoffs in affordability, housing, taxes, politics, climate, and day-to-day living are easy to scan.
Overall Affordability
Alabama is 44.1 points cheaper overall
Alabama has the lower cost-of-living index. Alabama is at 88.6, while New York is at 132.7.
View detailed comparison
Real Dollar Value
$100 goes $26.32 further in Alabama
After BEA price-level adjustments, $100 has about $114.62 of local buying power in Alabama, versus $88.30 in New York.
View detailed comparison
Income
New York income is 43.1% higher
New York has the higher median household income at $78,609, compared with $54,943 in Alabama.
View detailed comparison
Jobs
New York minimum wage is $9.25 higher
New York has the higher statewide minimum wage at $16.50/hr, compared with $7.25/hr in Alabama.
View detailed comparison
Housing
New York homes cost about 2.1x more
Alabama has the lower median home value at $174,600, versus $367,200 in New York.
View detailed comparison
Taxes
Alabama has lower state income tax
Alabama has the lower state income tax rate. Its top rate is 5.00%, compared with 10.90% in New York.
View detailed comparisonTake-Home Calculator
What's Your Salary Really Worth?
Enter your gross income to see real purchasing power and the cost-of-living equivalent in both states.
$
$10k$250k$500k
Alabama
- Gross salary
- —
- State income tax (top rate 5.0%)
- —
- After state tax
- —
- Real buying power (BEA RPP)
- —
New York
- Gross salary
- —
- State income tax (top rate 10.9%)
- —
- After state tax
- —
- Real buying power (BEA RPP)
- —
Cost-of-Living Equivalent
—
* "After state tax" uses the top marginal rate — actual effective rate is lower for most incomes. Real buying power uses BEA Regional Price Parity (87.2 for Alabama, 114.8 for New York). COL equivalent uses the MERIC/C2ER composite index.
Tradeoffs
Pros and cons for each state
A fast scan of the biggest advantages and drawbacks pulled from affordability, housing, income, taxes, safety, health, education, jobs, and weather.
Alabama
At-a-glance strengths and tradeoffs
Pros: Alabama
- Alabama has a lower overall cost of living.
- Alabama has a lower housing cost index.
- Alabama has lower median home values.
- Alabama has lower property tax rates on average.
- Alabama has more sunny days.
Cons
- Alabama shows lower median income.
- Alabama has a higher violent crime rate.
- Alabama job growth trend is weaker.
- Alabama health access/outcomes proxy is lower.
- Alabama health coverage access proxy is weaker.
- Alabama education proxy is lower.
New York
At-a-glance strengths and tradeoffs
Pros: New York
- New York shows higher median income.
- New York has a lower violent crime rate.
- New York job growth trend is stronger.
- New York health access/outcomes proxy is higher.
- New York health coverage access proxy is stronger.
- New York education proxy is higher.
Cons
- New York has a higher overall cost of living.
- New York has a higher housing cost index.
- New York has higher median home values.
- New York has higher property tax rates on average.
- New York has fewer sunny days.
Full Comparison
Pick a category to focus on. General shows the most important facts at a glance.
| Metric |
AL
|
NY
|
|---|---|---|
|
Capital City
|
Montgomery | Albany |
|
State Color
|
Solid Red | Solid Blue |
|
Population
|
5,024,279
|
20,201,249
|
|
Median Income
|
$54,943
|
$78,609
|
|
Cost of Living
|
88.6
|
132.7
|
|
Median Housing Value
|
$174,600
|
$367,200
|
|
Property Tax
|
0.38%
|
1.55%
|
|
State Income Tax
|
5.00%
|
10.90%
|
|
Minimum Wage
|
$7.25/hr
|
$16.50/hr
|
|
Gas Price
|
$3.840/gal
|
$4.069/gal
|
|
Electricity Rates
|
16.06 c/kWh
|
28.37 c/kWh
|
|
Livability Score
|
47.01
|
57.94
|
|
Average Temperature
|
62.8°F
|
45.4°F
|
|
Sunny Days
|
99 days
|
63 days
|
|
Land Area
|
52,419 sq mi
|
54,555 sq mi
|
|
Population Density
|
95.8 per sq mi
|
370.3 per sq mi
|
|
Statehood
|
December 14, 1819 (#22)
|
July 26, 1788 (#11)
|
Intent-Oriented
Which state fits your priorities better?
Use these cards as decision shortcuts for common goals like saving money, buying a home, finding better weather, or optimizing for work and family life.
6
of
19
shown
Saving Money
Alabama is cheaper overall
Overall cost-of-living index: 88.6 vs 132.7 in New York. On a national baseline of 100, the lower score usually means cheaper day-to-day expenses.
See full data
Gas Price
Alabama is cheaper at the pump
Average regular gas price: $3.840/gal in Alabama vs $4.069/gal in New York. Lower pump prices can cut everyday driving costs.
See full data
Minimum Wage
New York has the higher minimum wage
State minimum wage: $16.50/hr in New York vs $7.25/hr in Alabama. That matters most for hourly, entry-level, and part-time workers.
See full data
Electricity Rates
Alabama has cheaper electricity
Average residential electricity rate: 16.06 c/kWh in Alabama vs 28.37 c/kWh in New York. Lower cents-per-kWh pricing can help keep utility bills down.
See full data
Buying a Home
Alabama is more attainable for buyers
Home-value-to-income ratio: 3.18x in Alabama vs 4.67x in New York. A lower ratio means the median home is easier to afford on a median income.
See full data
Renting
Alabama is easier for renters
Rent-to-income ratio: 20.2% in Alabama vs 24.1% in New York. A lower percentage means rent takes a smaller bite out of a typical household budget.
See full dataExplore by Category
Dive Deeper
Each link opens a full one-on-one breakdown for that metric — national rankings, charts, and context.
People Also Ask
Alabama vs New York - Common Questions
Q Is Alabama cheaper to live in than New York?
Alabama has the lower cost of living. On the national index (100 = average), Alabama scores 88.6 versus 132.7 for New York - a gap of 44.1 points.
Q Where does $100 go further - Alabama or New York?
$100 goes further in Alabama. After BEA regional price adjustments, $100 is worth about $114.62 in Alabama, compared with $88.30 in New York.
Q Which state is bigger - Alabama or New York?
New York is larger, covering 54,555 sq mi compared with 52,419 sq mi for Alabama - roughly 1.0x the size.
Q Does Alabama or New York have more people?
New York has the larger population at 20,201,249, compared with 5,024,279 in Alabama.
Q Which state has higher household income - Alabama or New York?
New York has the higher median household income at $78,609, versus $54,943 in Alabama.
Q Which state has lower income taxes - Alabama or New York?
Alabama has the lower state income tax top rate at 5.00%, compared with 10.90% in New York.
Q Is housing cheaper in Alabama or New York?
Homes are cheaper in Alabama, where the median home value is $174,600, versus $367,200 in New York.
Q Which state is more densely populated - Alabama or New York?
New York is more densely populated at 370.3 per sq mi people per sq mi. Alabama is more spread out at 95.8 per sq mi people per sq mi.
Related Comparisons
Methodology
All figures are sourced from U.S. government datasets and updated annually. Page last updated: April 2026.
Core demographic data comes from the 2020 U.S. Census, with land area from U.S. Census Bureau TIGER files and statehood dates from the National Archives. Income, housing, affordability, and tax fields are maintained in our comparison dataset; purchasing-power figures use BEA Regional Price Parities. Minimum wage data comes from the U.S. Department of Labor, gas prices from AAA, and electricity rates from the U.S. Energy Information Administration. Political control and election fields use 2024 presidential results together with National Conference of State Legislatures data. Gun-law labels use the Giffords scorecard, alcohol system data comes from NABCA, and marijuana status uses NCSL's state cannabis laws tracker. See our editorial policy for how we review and update these pages.